I was skeptical of theses after some reviews saying the bags slip through. So far so good. Holds as advertised for our dogs.

I LOVE this brand but unfortunately, I returned this. The poop bags, even when double tied, still slipped out. I like a different brand more. I think it's a solid construction and could be great for some but just didn't work for me. Other items are the best!!!

I bought two of these loops, one for each dog. They are very tiny and it’s difficult to push knot through. Now they are both missing- must have fallen off leash. Really want to love them

It took me a minute to appreciate this one compared to others I’ve used. Because it’s so small and light, I had to work harder to get the bag into the loop. Then I realized two things—pushing through the knot itself, rather than the top of of the bag was faster. And I didn’t need to be delicate, because there’s a lifetime warranty. If the loop were a little stiffer it would be easier, but I’ll take the trade off for something so small and light!

In all honesty I didn’t think much of this, as it was a free add on with my order. But after using for a week or so, it’s become a very useful part of if my walking gear.